star

Animation Critique Workshop

Information

  • Public (anyone can view and join)
  • If you're interested in getting some feedback on your 2d or 3d animation, post your shot here and we will discuss it. Anyone is welcome to add their thoughts about a shot or exercise. One of the best ways to learn animation is to observe and give feedback on other peoples scenes.  So feel free to join! 

Recent Activities

  • star
    Louise Eacott
    Hi guys,
    I would love some feedback on this shot I've been working on before I start polishing. Thankyou
  • star
    Alex Haney
    Hi everyone,

    So this is my first time posting here. Hopefully I'm doing this right. I'm trying to get the swing of the arms to work naturally here, but it just doesn't feel right still. This is where they're at right now... any advice would be really, really appreciated! Doesn't have to be just the arms, any critique of any kind is welcome! Thanks.
    • comment View all comments
    • Mario Furmanczyk
    • Siroj
  • star
    Josh Hill
    Here's the first 2D test of the ghost character for our 4th year film! So much fun
    Instagram
    200 Likes, 27 Comments - Josh Hill (@joshhilldraws) on Instagram: “Finally got some time to do a rough test of the ghost character for our 4th...
    • comment View all 3 comments
    • Mario Furmanczyk
    • Josh Hill
  • star
    Mark-Leon Rivera
    Haven't done one in awhile, what do you guys think?
    • comment View all comments
    • Siroj
    • Davies Rushing
  • star
    Valerii Balan
    Hi) I'm game animator and this is my very first feature animation. Now almost all the animation is blocking I've polished only for first 100 frms. What do you think about it?
    I really want to improve the animation but I do not know how)
    • Jessica Roberts
    • Mario Furmanczyk
  • star
    Fabio Pugliese
    Hey, guys! I'd like to show you my new personal study and I'd be glad to see your notes. Please, let me know how to impove that! See you!
  • star
    Ashley Caballero
    Did an animation of this character juggling and eating the color balls (which I'm gonna replace with cupcakes) and need a constructive critique for his, cuz it was really hard to animate this
  • star
    Feel free to comment
    Here's some walk cycle, did it for fun for one evening :)
    • Mario Furmanczyk
  • star
    Davies Rushing
    Here's an update of the animation I shared yesterday. Today, I just focused on making the weight more believable and I cut out the last line that I felt wasn't necessary. Thanks!
    • Mario Furmanczyk
    • Scott Fuller
  • star
    Davies Rushing
    Hi everyone! I would love some critique on this animation that I did a few months ago!! Thank you (:
    • comment View all comments
    • Mario Furmanczyk
    • Davies Rushing
  • star
    Tyree Morrow
    Animation from a personal project. The character is Hermes commentating a baseball game. He's saying "What an amazing game!" Then flies in to get a closer look. Critiques and tips welcomed.

    https://vimeo.com/224243881
    Rough pencil test animation of Hermes for a short i'm working on.
    • Mario Furmanczyk
  • star
    Siroj
    This is for animation competition, where character must be primitive and feel any emotion. What do you think about this ?)
    • Mark-Leon Rivera